Abdellah's 21 nursing problems were set out in 1960 by American nurse scholar and public health leader Faye Glenn Abdellah and colleagues in Patient-Centered Approaches to Nursing. Seeing nursing as patient-centred rather than disease-centred, she classified the problems nurses must assess and solve into 21 items in four areas: sustenal, nourishment, remedial and restorative care needs. Defining nursing as scientific problem solving, the framework paved the way for the nursing process and nursing diagnosis.
Key takeaways
- Nursing identifies and solves the patient’s 21 nursing problems.
- Problems are overt (apparent) or covert (hidden); she stressed not missing hidden emotional and social problems.
- Abdellah was the first nurse to serve as US Deputy Surgeon General and helped institutionalise nursing research.
Who developed it and why
Faye Glenn Abdellah (1919–2017) grew up in New Jersey. By her own account, feeling helpless when the airship Hindenburg exploded at Lakehurst in 1937 pushed her toward nursing. After nursing school she earned bachelor’s, master’s and doctoral degrees at Teachers College, Columbia University, and taught at Yale School of Nursing from 1945 to 1949.
At Yale she was frustrated that nursing education guidelines had little scientific basis. She went on to spend nearly 40 years in the US Public Health Service, and from the 1950s worked with Eugene Levine on measures of patient and staff satisfaction and on the quality of hospital nursing. At a time when nursing was seen as assisting the doctor, she wanted to define the patient problems nurses identify and solve in their own right, and the 21 problems of 1960 were the result. From 1981 to 1989 she was the first nurse and first woman to serve as US Deputy Surgeon General, and she led the founding of the National Institute of Nursing Research.
Core concepts of 21 nursing problems
- Nursing problem — A condition of the patient or family that the nurse can help with through professional functions; overt or covert.
- Overt problems — Readily observed, such as pain, immobility or poor nutrition.
- Covert problems — Emotional, social or interpersonal problems that are not obvious and easily missed.
- Sustenal care needs (1–4) — 1 hygiene and comfort; 2 activity, exercise, rest and sleep; 3 safety and infection control; 4 body mechanics and preventing deformity.
- Nourishment care needs (5–11) — 5 oxygen; 6 nutrition; 7 elimination; 8 fluid and electrolytes; 9 physiological responses to disease; 10 regulatory mechanisms; 11 sensory function.
- Remedial care needs (12–17) — 12 expressing feelings; 13 emotion and organic illness; 14 communication; 15 interpersonal relationships; 16 spiritual goals; 17 therapeutic environment.
- Restorative care needs (18–21) — 18 individuality; 19 accepting optimal attainable goals; 20 community resources; 21 social problems influencing illness.
- Problem solving — Nursing as data collection, problem identification, planning, implementation and evaluation.
Research and evidence behind 21 nursing problems
Abdellah’s framework came not from a lab but from public health research trying to measure the quality of hospital nursing. These are its propositions and the research behind it.
Propositions (testable hypotheses)
- The quality of nursing can be measured through events (satisfactions and dissatisfactions) experienced by patients and staff.
- The more systematically nurses identify patients’ problems, the more patient-centred care becomes.
- Unless hidden emotional and social problems are addressed, solving overt physical problems is limited.
- Nursing problems are solved more effectively through a scientific problem-solving process.
Key studies and findings
- Satisfaction measure (1957, Abdellah and Levine): a tool measuring satisfaction from what patients and staff experienced in hospital, published in Nursing Research; an early attempt to compare nursing quality objectively.
- Hospital nursing studies (1950s): using the tool across hospitals, they examined staffing and patient and staff experience and recorded systematically which patient problems nurses dealt with, groundwork for the 21 problems.
- Patient-Centered Approaches to Nursing (1960): Abdellah, Beland, Martin and Matheney set out the 21 problems and the problem-solving process, proposing that curricula be reorganised around patient problems rather than diseases.
- Systematising nursing research (1965): with Levine she wrote Better Patient Care Through Nursing Research, a guide to designing and conducting nursing studies.
- Overview of nursing research (1970): reviewed nursing research from 1955 to 1968, documenting nursing’s emergence as a research field.
Her concept of nursing problems fed into the nursing diagnosis classification of NANDA in the 1970s and is a distant ancestor of today’s diagnosis lists.
Key assumptions
- Nursing should be patient-centred: the patient’s problems, not the disease, are the focus.
- Nurses must identify both overt and covert problems accurately.
- Solving nursing problems should rest on scientific method and research.
- Nurses help patients with what they cannot do and teach self-help.
21 nursing problems and the nursing metaparadigm
| Metaparadigm concept | How this theory defines it |
|---|---|
| Person | A recipient of nursing with physical, emotional, social and spiritual needs. |
| Environment | Not clearly defined; addressed as the therapeutic environment and community resources. |
| Health | A state without deficits or unmet needs; the goal of nursing. |
| Nursing | A comprehensive service, art and science of identifying and solving the 21 problems. |
Applying 21 nursing problems to the nursing process: a case example
Using the 21-problem list to find both overt and covert problems.
Case Woman, 66, two weeks on a rehabilitation ward with left-sided weakness after a stroke. Dysphagia, eats half her meals, refuses exercises: "I’m just a burden to my family." Her husband visits daily but they hardly talk.
| Nursing process step | Application |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Overt: 2 activity, 4 body mechanics, 6 nutrition (50% intake), 3 aspiration and fall risk / Covert: 12 expressing feelings, 13 emotion and illness (low mood), 15 relationship with husband, 19 accepting attainable goals |
| Diagnosis | Impaired swallowing; risk for imbalanced nutrition; risk for falls; situational low self-esteem |
| Planning | Within a week she eats ≥75%, joins exercises at least once a day and talks about her feelings with the nurse or her husband |
| Implementation | Sustenal/nourishment: dysphagia diet, posture and pacing, fall prevention / Remedial: conversations that invite feelings, screen for depression and refer, time with her husband / Restorative: small goals (lifting a cup alone), information on community rehabilitation and peer groups |
| Evaluation | After a week intake 80%, smiles: "I lifted the cup myself", discusses goals with her husband: goals met; repeat depression screening |
This is a fictional teaching case. Real patient care must follow local protocols and the judgment of the treating team.
Strengths and limitations
Strengths
- Lists concrete problems, so it works as an assessment tool.
- Emphasises hidden emotional and social problems, supporting holistic care.
- Defining nursing as scientific problem solving laid foundations for the nursing process and diagnosis.
Limitations
- A nurse-centred "problem" view that gives less weight to strengths and health promotion.
- The 21 items overlap and their classification basis is unclear.
- Few propositions explaining relationships among person, environment and health.
How it compares with related theories
| Aspect | Abdellah | Henderson | Nursing diagnosis (NANDA-I) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Focus | Patient problems for nurses to solve | Patient’s basic needs | Standardised nursing judgments |
| View | Problem solving | Need fulfilment and independence | Diagnostic taxonomy |
| Date | 1960 | 1960/1966 | 1973 onward |
Compare Henderson's 14 basic needs, nursing diagnosis, which grew from the idea of nursing problems, and the nursing process.
Related nursing theory pages
- Nursing theory overview (hub page)
- Henderson's Need Theory (14 Basic Needs)
- Nursing diagnosis (NANDA-I)
- Nursing process
- Orem's Self-Care Deficit Theory
- Classification of nursing theories
- Nightingale's Environmental Theory
FAQ
- What are the four areas?
- Sustenal (1–4), nourishment (5–11), remedial (12–17) and restorative (18–21) care needs.
- Overt versus covert problems?
- Overt problems are readily observed; covert problems, such as emotional or social ones, are hidden.
- How does it differ from Henderson?
- Henderson listed 14 basic patient needs; Abdellah listed 21 problems for nurses to solve.
- Why does it matter?
- It moved nursing from disease-centred to patient-centred problem solving and underpinned the nursing process and nursing diagnosis.
- Who was Abdellah?
- A nursing research pioneer in the US Public Health Service and, from 1981 to 1989, the first nurse and woman to serve as US Deputy Surgeon General.
Sources reviewed: 2026-11-20
References
- Abdellah, F. G., Beland, I. L., Martin, A., & Matheney, R. V. (1960). Patient-centered approaches to nursing. Macmillan. The original book presenting the 21 nursing problems.
- Abdellah, F. G., & Levine, E. (1957). Developing a measure of patient and personnel satisfaction with nursing care. Nursing Research, 5(3), 100–108. Abdellah's early study developing a satisfaction measure for patients and staff.
- Abdellah, F. G., & Levine, E. (1965). Better patient care through nursing research. Macmillan. A classic text systematising nursing research methods.
- Abdellah, F. G. (1970). Overview of nursing research 1955–1968, Part II. Nursing Research, 19(2), 151–162. An overview of nursing research from 1955 to 1968.
- Abdellah, F. G., Beland, I. L., Martin, A., & Matheney, R. V. (1973). New directions in patient-centered nursing. Macmillan. The follow-up book revising and extending the framework.
- Henderson, V. (1966). The nature of nursing. Macmillan. Henderson's 14 basic needs, often compared with Abdellah.
- Alligood, M. R. (Ed.). (2021). Nursing theorists and their work (10th ed.). Elsevier. Textbook covering Abdellah among other theorists.