Tanner's clinical judgment model was published in 2006 by American nurse scholar Christine Tanner after synthesising about 200 studies. It describes "thinking like a nurse" in four phases: noticing, interpreting, responding and reflecting. Its central claim is that judgment depends more on what the nurse brings, the context and knowing the patient than on objective data. It shaped simulation assessment (the LCJR) and the clinical judgment measurement model behind the Next Generation NCLEX.
Key takeaways
- Four phases: noticing → interpreting → responding → reflecting (in action and on action).
- Judgment starts from the nurse’s background, the context and the relationship with the patient.
- Interpretation uses analytic, intuitive and narrative reasoning, alone or together.
Who developed it and why
Christine A. Tanner was a professor at Oregon Health & Science University School of Nursing and for many years editor of the Journal of Nursing Education. In the 1980s she applied methods from research on physicians’ diagnostic reasoning to nursing, analysing think-aloud responses of 15 junior students, 13 senior students and 15 nurses to videotaped cases (1987). Around the same time she studied expert nurses’ intuition with Patricia Benner (1987).
As research accumulated, Tanner noticed a gap. Nursing education had long taught the nursing process (assess, diagnose, plan, implement, evaluate) as the way to think, but studies showed real judgment was not that linear. She reviewed about 200 studies of clinical judgment, drew five conclusions, and in 2006 offered an alternative model closer to how nurses actually think.
Core concepts of Clinical judgment model
- Clinical judgment — Interpreting a patient’s needs, concerns or health problems and deciding whether and how to act.
- Noticing — Grasping the situation; expectations, knowing the patient and context shape what stands out.
- Interpreting — Understanding what has been noticed and deciding on an appropriate response.
- Responding — Choosing and carrying out a course of action, including deciding to do nothing.
- Reflecting — Reflection-in-action (reading the patient’s response and adjusting) and reflection-on-action (learning from experience).
- Analytic reasoning — Breaking data down and testing hypotheses, used when experience is limited or things do not fit.
- Intuitive reasoning — Immediate grasp of a situation through pattern recognition from experience.
- Narrative reasoning — Making sense of a situation through the patient’s story and cases.
Research and evidence behind Clinical judgment model
Tanner’s model came not from a single experiment but from a synthesis of decades of judgment research. These are the conclusions behind it and the key studies.
Propositions (testable hypotheses)
- Clinical judgments are influenced more by what nurses bring (knowledge, experience, values) than by the objective data.
- Sound judgment rests partly on knowing the patient and their typical responses and engaging with their concerns.
- Judgment is influenced by context and the culture of the unit.
- Nurses use a variety of reasoning patterns alone or in combination.
- Reflection is often triggered by a breakdown in judgment and is critical to clinical knowledge and better reasoning.
Key studies and findings
- Diagnostic reasoning of nurses and students (1987): think-aloud responses from 15 junior students, 13 senior students and 15 nurses to three videotaped vignettes. All activated diagnostic hypotheses early and gathered data systematically to rule them in or out; with more knowledge and experience, data gathering became more systematic and diagnosis more accurate.
- Expert intuition (1987, with Benner): described how proficient nurses grasp situations through pattern recognition and a sense that "something is wrong", the basis of the model’s intuitive reasoning.
- Review of about 200 studies (2006): yielded the five conclusions above and a four-phase model centred on the nurse’s background, the context and the relationship with the patient.
- Lasater Clinical Judgment Rubric (2007): an exploratory study created and pilot-tested the rubric in a simulation lab; it now splits the four phases into 11 dimensions to describe students’ development.
- Integration with the NCSBN model (2019): a multidisciplinary team compared the NCSBN clinical judgment model with three leading educational frameworks, including Tanner’s, linking teaching and testing.
The model began with evidence that the nursing process alone does not capture real judgment, and it has become the shared language of nursing education and licensure.
Key assumptions
- Judgments are influenced more by what nurses bring than by objective data.
- Sound judgment rests partly on knowing the patient and engaging with their concerns.
- Judgment is influenced by context and unit culture.
- Reflection is often triggered by a breakdown in judgment and is critical for clinical learning.
Clinical judgment model and the nursing metaparadigm
| Metaparadigm concept | How this theory defines it |
|---|---|
| Person | A person with typical patterns of response and concerns whom the nurse must come to know. |
| Environment | The context and culture of the unit and working relationships. |
| Health | Not defined directly; the aim of judgment is patient well-being and safety. |
| Nursing | The practical activity of noticing, interpreting, responding and reflecting. |
Applying Clinical judgment model to the nursing process: a case example
A new nurse’s judgment traced through Tanner’s four phases.
Case Man, 71, day 2 after colectomy. Vital signs within normal range (pulse 98, BP 118/70) but quieter than yesterday, "just tired". New graduate, one month in post. Urine output 100 mL over 4 hours.
| Nursing process step | Application |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Noticing: pulse up from 78 yesterday, change in mental status, low urine output (25 mL/h) / Background: knowledge of post-operative complications and of "yesterday’s patient" |
| Diagnosis | Interpreting (analytic): sepsis, bleeding or fluid deficit? Risk for deficient fluid volume; risk for infection (early sepsis suspected) |
| Planning | Within 2 hours the cause is identified, urine output ≥30 mL/h and mental status returns to baseline |
| Implementation | Responding: recheck temperature, respiratory rate and glucose; assess abdomen and wound; SBAR report to the doctor and senior nurse; start prescribed fluids / Reflection-in-action: reassess in 30 minutes |
| Evaluation | Temperature 38.2 °C, RR 24: positive sepsis screen, early treatment begun / Reflection-on-action: "normal range is not enough; look at trends and the patient’s usual self" |
This is a fictional teaching case. Real patient care must follow local protocols and the judgment of the treating team.
Strengths and limitations
Strengths
- Closer to real thinking than the nursing process and grounded in about 200 studies.
- Ready to use for simulation assessment (LCJR) and debriefing.
- Makes reflection a core phase, showing how nurses learn from experience.
Limitations
- More an educational model than a theory of nursing practice as a whole.
- Background and context are hard to measure directly.
- Focuses on individual judgment rather than team decisions.
How it compares with related theories
| Aspect | Tanner | Nursing process | Benner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Structure | Notice, interpret, respond, reflect | Assess, diagnose, plan, implement, evaluate | Five skill levels |
| Reasoning | Analytic, intuitive and narrative | Mainly analytic, linear | Growth of intuition |
| Main use | Teaching and assessing judgment | Documentation and planning | Career development |
See Benner's novice to expert for the growth of intuition, the nursing process, and Carper's patterns of knowing.
Related nursing theory pages
- Nursing theory overview (hub page)
- Benner's From Novice to Expert
- Nursing process
- Nursing diagnosis (NANDA-I)
- Carper's patterns of knowing
- Classification of nursing theories
FAQ
- What are the four phases?
- Noticing, interpreting, responding and reflecting.
- How does it differ from the nursing process?
- The nursing process is a linear problem-solving procedure; Tanner’s model describes actual thinking, including background, context and intuition.
- What is it based on?
- Five conclusions from a review of about 200 studies of clinical judgment.
- What is the LCJR?
- Lasater’s rubric built on the model, rating the four phases across 11 dimensions at four levels (beginning, developing, accomplished, exemplary).
- Is it linked to the NCLEX?
- Yes. The NCSBN clinical judgment measurement model behind the Next Generation NCLEX (2023) was compared with and integrated into frameworks such as Tanner’s.
Sources reviewed: 2026-11-20
References
- Tanner, C. A. (2006). Thinking like a nurse: A research-based model of clinical judgment in nursing. Journal of Nursing Education, 45(6), 204–211. The original paper synthesising about 200 studies into the four-phase model.
- Tanner, C. A., Padrick, K. P., Westfall, U. E., & Putzier, D. J. (1987). Diagnostic reasoning strategies of nurses and nursing students. Nursing Research, 36(6), 358–363. Tanner's early study comparing diagnostic reasoning in nurses and students.
- Benner, P., & Tanner, C. (1987). Clinical judgment: How expert nurses use intuition. American Journal of Nursing, 87(1), 23–31. Joint work with Benner on how expert nurses use intuition.
- Lasater, K. (2007). Clinical judgment development: Using simulation to create an assessment rubric. Journal of Nursing Education, 46(11), 496–503. Creates the Lasater Clinical Judgment Rubric from Tanner's model.
- Dickison, P., Haerling, K. A., & Lasater, K. (2019). Integrating the National Council of State Boards of Nursing Clinical Judgment Model into nursing educational frameworks. Journal of Nursing Education, 58(2), 72–78. Relates the NCSBN clinical judgment model to Tanner's model.
- Kim, E. (2014). Nursing students' clinical judgment skills in simulation: Using Tanner's clinical judgment model. Journal of Korean Academic Society of Nursing Education, 20(2), 212–222. Applies the model to Korean nursing students in simulation.
- Benner, P., Tanner, C. A., & Chesla, C. A. (2009). Expertise in nursing practice: Caring, clinical judgment, and ethics (2nd ed.). Springer Publishing. Joint book on expertise, clinical judgment and ethics.