The care, core and cure theory is a nursing model set out in the early 1960s by American rehabilitation nurse Lydia Hall. Hall pictured the patient as three overlapping circles. Care is the body, the nurse’s own domain; core is the person coming to understand themselves through a therapeutic relationship; cure is treatment of disease shared with the medical team. She argued that as medical care decreases, the need for professional nursing and teaching increases, and tested the idea in 1963 at the Loeb Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation in the Bronx, New York.
Key takeaways
- The essence of nursing is nurturing; intimate bodily care is the path to the person.
- For convalescent patients, professional nurses, not physicians, should be at the centre of care.
- The Loeb Center admitted post-acute patients and had registered nurses give direct care: a nurse-led facility.
Who developed it and why
Lydia E. Hall (1906–1969) was born in Pennsylvania, graduated from York Hospital School of Nursing in 1927 and earned a BS (1932) and MA (1942) at Teachers College, Columbia. Working across public health, chronic illness care and nursing education, she saw hospitals either discharging patients after acute treatment before they had recovered or keeping them in costly acute beds. What convalescent patients needed, she believed, was not more medical procedures but professional nursing that cared for the body and helped them understand themselves.
With Montefiore Hospital she opened the Loeb Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation in the Bronx in 1963. It admitted patients from acute units who were past physiological crisis but still needed 24-hour nursing and daily evaluation; registered nurses gave the direct care and physicians acted as consultants. There Hall defined nursing as a process of nurturing that fosters growth and development toward wellness, and in 1964 set out the three-circle model in Nursing: What Is It? She died in 1969, but the Center continued under her successor, Genrose Alfano.
Core concepts of Care, core and cure
- Care: the body — Intimate bodily care such as bathing, feeding, positioning and comfort; nursing’s exclusive domain and a route to closeness with the patient.
- Core: the person — The patient as person. Through therapeutic use of self and reflective conversation the nurse helps the patient understand feelings, motives and goals.
- Cure: the disease — Medical treatment such as drugs, procedures and tests, shared with physicians and other professionals.
- Overlapping circles — The circles overlap and change size with the patient’s state: cure is largest in the acute phase, care and core in recovery.
- Nurturing — Nursing as a process that fosters growth and development toward wellness.
- Reflective technique — Mirroring the patient’s words so they understand themselves better, influenced by Carl Rogers’s client-centred approach.
- Professional nursing — The principle that recovery is faster when registered nurses give direct care.
- Loeb Center — The nurse-led convalescent facility opened with Montefiore Hospital in 1963; the theory’s testing ground.
Research and evidence behind Care, core and cure
Hall’s theory is a rare case of a model tested not in a laboratory but in a real facility, a nurse-led hospital. These are its propositions and the records of the Loeb Center.
Propositions (testable hypotheses)
- Post-acute convalescent patients need professional nursing and teaching more than medical treatment.
- When registered nurses give direct care, recovery is faster and readmissions fall.
- Intimate bodily care is the pathway to the patient’s core, their understanding of themselves.
- Motivation and recovery grow when patients find their own goals.
Key studies and findings
- Opening of the Loeb Center (1962–1963): Lucille Petry Leone, chief nurse of the US Public Health Service, gave the dedication address in November 1962, and the Center opened with Montefiore Hospital in 1963. Records preserve its admission criteria: post-acute patients past physiological crisis who still needed 24-hour nursing and daily evaluation.
- A Center for Nursing (1963) and Nursing: What Is It? (1964): Hall described the Center’s design and set out the three circles and the principle that nursing grows as medical care shrinks.
- Reports on the Center (1969, Hall; Alfano): Hall detailed its operating principles in the International Journal of Nursing Studies, and her successor Alfano described its professional practice, with registered nurses giving direct care.
- Final report on long-term effects (1975, Hall, Alfano, Rifkin and Levine): Longitudinal Effects of an Experimental Nursing Process evaluated how Loeb Center nursing affected patients after discharge. The report is held in the Loeb Center records (MC 117) at the University of Pennsylvania’s Barbara Bates Center.
- Theoretical appraisal (1980, Wiggins): although Hall left no formal theory book, Wiggins judged her definition of nursing’s own domain and nurse-led practice an important place in nursing theory development.
Long-term outcome data from the Loeb Center survive mainly as reports, so specific figures are hard to confirm in the open literature. Still, the idea of a nurse-led convalescent unit is seen as a forerunner of today’s nurse-led clinics and transitional care models.
Key assumptions
- The essence of nursing is nurturing; caring for the body is a uniquely nursing function.
- The less medical care, the more professional nursing and teaching are needed.
- Patients recover best when they find and pursue their own goals.
- Recovery is faster when professional nurses give direct care.
Care, core and cure and the nursing metaparadigm
| Metaparadigm concept | How this theory defines it |
|---|---|
| Person | Adult patients with body, person and disease aspects, able to find their own goals and recover. |
| Environment | A therapeutic environment for recovery, nurse-centred like the Loeb Center. |
| Health | Understanding oneself and achieving self-chosen goals toward wellness. |
| Nursing | Professional activity of caring for the body (care), helping the person understand themselves (core) and sharing in treatment (cure). |
Applying Care, core and cure to the nursing process: a case example
Assessing and caring for a convalescent patient with Hall’s three circles.
Case Woman, 79, day 10 on a rehabilitation ward after hip replacement following a fall. The wound is healing and pain controlled, but she avoids walking practice and stays in bed: "What’s the point at my age?" She lives alone and worries whether she can go home.
| Nursing process step | Application |
|---|---|
| Assessment | Cure (disease): wound fine, analgesia once or twice a day, medical treatment winding down / Care (body): weakness, constipation, poor sleep / Core (person): fear of not walking again, anxiety about living alone, no self-chosen goal |
| Diagnosis | Impaired physical mobility; risk for powerlessness; risk for falls |
| Planning | Within a week she states her own discharge goal and walks the ward corridor twice a day with a frame |
| Implementation | Care: do her morning hygiene and repositioning personally as chances to talk; bowel care / Core: reflective questions such as "What would you most like to do when you get home?" to find a goal: "Make birthday seaweed soup for my grandson myself" / Cure: coordinate walking plan with physiotherapist and doctor; arrange home nursing |
| Evaluation | Day 5: "I’ll have to walk to the kitchen to make that soup," and she starts walking; after a week, two corridor laps: goal met; home assessment before discharge |
This is a fictional teaching case. Real patient care must follow local protocols and the judgment of the treating team.
Strengths and limitations
Strengths
- Clarifies nursing’s distinct role in convalescence and created a model for nurse-led facilities.
- Re-values bodily care as a pathway to relationship, not a menial task.
- Having patients find their own goals suits self-management and rehabilitation.
Limitations
- Focused on post-acute adults, so hard to apply to children, acute care or the community.
- Requiring registered nurses for all direct care raises staffing and cost burdens.
- Concepts are broad, and long-term outcome data are limited in the published literature.
How it compares with related theories
| Aspect | Hall | Henderson | Orem |
|---|---|---|---|
| Focus | Body, person and disease of convalescent patients | Basic needs and independence | Self-care deficits |
| Nurse role | Professional nursing and reflective conversation | Supply missing strength, will or knowledge | Design compensatory and educative systems |
| Practice model | Loeb Center (nurse-led facility) | No specific facility | Theory of nursing systems |
For basic needs see Henderson's 14 basic needs; for self-care, Orem's self-care deficit theory; for starting from the client’s view, Erickson's Modeling and Role-Modeling.
Related nursing theory pages
- Nursing theory overview (hub page)
- Orem's Self-Care Deficit Theory
- Henderson's Need Theory (14 Basic Needs)
- Peplau's Theory of Interpersonal Relations
- Individual and Family Self-Management Theory (Ryan and Sawin)
- Classification of nursing theories
- Modeling and Role-Modeling theory (Erickson)
FAQ
- What are the three circles?
- Care is the body, core is the person and cure is the disease.
- Which circle belongs only to nursing?
- Care, the bodily care circle; nurses are also deeply involved in the core through the therapeutic relationship.
- What was the Loeb Center?
- A nurse-led convalescent facility opened with Montefiore Hospital in the Bronx in 1963, where Hall tested her theory.
- Why should nursing grow as medical care shrinks?
- For convalescent patients, nursing and teaching that care for the body and help them find their own goals drive recovery more than procedures.
- Who was Hall?
- An American rehabilitation and public health nurse who founded the Loeb Center in 1963 and led it until 1969.
Sources reviewed: 2026-11-20
References
- Hall, L. E. (1963). A center for nursing. Nursing Outlook, 11, 805–806. Hall’s description of the Loeb Center as it opened.
- Hall, L. E. (1964). Nursing: What is it? The Canadian Nurse, 60, 150–154. Her key paper explaining the care, core and cure circles.
- Hall, L. E. (1969). The Loeb Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation, Montefiore Hospital and Medical Center, Bronx, New York. International Journal of Nursing Studies, 6(2), 81–97. Detailed account of how the Loeb Center worked.
- Alfano, G. J. (1969). The Loeb Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation: A professional approach to nursing practice. Nursing Clinics of North America, 4(3), 487–493. Account by Hall’s successor of professional practice at the Center.
- Wiggins, L. R. (1980). Lydia Hall's place in the development of theory in nursing. Image, 12(1), 10–12. Assesses Hall’s place in nursing theory development.
- Hall, L. E., Alfano, G. J., Rifkin, E., & Levine, H. S. (1975). Longitudinal effects of an experimental nursing process (Final report). Loeb Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation. Final report evaluating the long-term effects of Loeb Center nursing.
- Barbara Bates Center for the Study of the History of Nursing. (n.d.). Loeb Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation records, MC 117. University of Pennsylvania. Archive finding aid confirming the Center’s founding and admission criteria.
- Alligood, M. R. (Ed.). (2021). Nursing theorists and their work (10th ed.). Elsevier. Textbook covering nursing theorists.