Definition
An existing crime plus a bias motive.
- Groups
- Race, religion, orientation, disability
- Approach
- Separate offense or sentence uplift
Hate speech vs hate crime
Hate speech concerns expression; hate crimes involve criminal acts.
Why enhance?
They send a message of threat to an entire community. *Wisconsin v. Mitchell* (1993) upheld enhancement.
Hate crimes are badly undercounted. If police do not record motive, they stay “ordinary assaults.”
Laws
US Shepard–Byrd Act (2009); UK mandatory uplift; Japan’s 2016 act has no penalties, though Kawasaki added criminal penalties in 2019; China punishes inciting ethnic hatred (Criminal Law Art. 249); Korea lacks a provision.
Frequently asked questions
- Is hate speech a hate crime?
- Not by itself.
References
- Matthew Shepard and James Byrd, Jr. Hate Crimes Prevention Act, 18 U.S.C. § 249 (2009).
- Hate Crime Statistics Act of 1990, 28 U.S.C. § 534 note (FBI, fbi.gov).
- UK Sentencing Act 2020, ss. 66–67.
- 日本「本邦外出身者に対する不当な差別的言動の解消に向けた取組の推進に関する法律」(2016年).
- 川崎市差別のない人権尊重のまちづくり条例(2019年12月制定).
- 中华人民共和国刑法 第二百四十九条、第二百五十条.
