What is the Bill of Rights? A quick summary
The Bill of Rights is the name for the first ten amendments to the U.S. Constitution. Congress proposed twelve amendments on September 25, 1789; ten were ratified by the states and took effect on December 15, 1791. The signed original is on display at the National Archives in Washington.
- Amendments
- 1 through 10
- Main author
- James Madison
- Originally limited
- Only the federal government (Barron v. Baltimore, 1833)
- Now limits
- States too, almost entirely, via the 14th Amendment
Fun leftover: one of the two amendments that didn't make it in 1791, about congressional pay raises, was finally ratified in 1992 as the 27th Amendment. Two hundred and two years later.
Why the Bill of Rights was added
The Constitution drafted at the Constitutional Convention of 1787 had almost no list of individual rights. Federalists like Alexander Hamilton argued one wasn't needed: the federal government only had the powers it was given, so why list things it couldn't do? In Federalist No. 84 he even warned a list could be dangerous, implying everything unlisted was fair game.
Anti-Federalists didn't buy it. They had just watched the weak Articles of Confederation fail and were afraid a strong new government would trample people instead. Several states ratified only with the understanding that amendments would follow.
Madison, who had been skeptical, ended up drafting them himself in the First Congress. Partly principle, partly politics: he'd promised voters in Virginia.
Most great political compromises leave both sides a little unhappy, and this one was no exception. The Federalists got their Constitution; the Anti-Federalists got a written promise. That promise turned out to matter far more than either side guessed in 1791.
What each amendment protects
| Amendment | Core protection |
|---|---|
| 1st | Religion (no establishment, free exercise), speech, press, assembly, petition. See First Amendment. |
| 2nd | Right to keep and bear arms. See Second Amendment. |
| 3rd | No quartering of soldiers in homes in peacetime without consent |
| 4th | No unreasonable searches and seizures; warrants need probable cause |
| 5th | Grand jury, no double jeopardy, no self-incrimination, due process, just compensation for takings |
| 6th | Speedy public jury trial, notice of charges, confront witnesses, counsel |
| 7th | Jury trial in federal civil cases over $20 |
| 8th | No excessive bail or fines, no cruel and unusual punishment |
| 9th | Listing some rights doesn't deny others the people keep |
| 10th | Powers not delegated to the U.S. are reserved to the states or the people |
Notice how much of it is about criminal justice. Amendments 4 through 8 are basically a manual for how the government must treat suspects. The 5th's due process language gets its own page: due process.
How the Bill of Rights came to bind the states
Here's the twist most people miss. In Barron v. Baltimore, 32 U.S. 243 (1833), Chief Justice Marshall held that the Bill of Rights restricted only the federal government. A state could, legally speaking, take your property without compensation.
The 14th Amendment (1868) changed the game, but slowly. Starting with Gitlow v. New York, 268 U.S. 652 (1925), the Court began "incorporating" rights into the 14th Amendment's Due Process Clause one by one:
- 1925–1940: speech, press, assembly, religion.
- 1961: Mapp v. Ohio, illegally seized evidence excluded in state courts.
- 1963: Gideon v. Wainwright, the right to a lawyer in state felony cases.
- 2010: McDonald v. Chicago, the Second Amendment.
- 2019: Timbs v. Indiana, the Excessive Fines Clause.
Still not incorporated: the Third Amendment (never really tested), the grand jury requirement, and the Seventh Amendment civil jury.
The Bill of Rights vs. Korean constitutional rights
Korea doesn't have a separate "bill" tacked on later. Rights sit inside the main text, in Chapter II, Articles 10 through 39, opening with human dignity and the pursuit of happiness (Art. 10). And Korea's list is longer, including social rights like education, work, and a decent living (Arts. 31–34), which the U.S. Constitution doesn't mention.
| U.S. Bill of Rights | Korean Constitution | |
|---|---|---|
| Form | Amendments added in 1791 | Built into Chapter II |
| Type of rights | Mostly "negative" liberties (government must not…) | Liberties plus social rights |
| Limits on rights | Judge-made tests (scrutiny levels) | Art. 37(2): only by law, when necessary, never the essence |
| Enforced by | All courts via judicial review | Constitutional Court, incl. constitutional complaints |
Cash Note
청년문화예술패스 하반기 추가 발급 — 2006·2007년생 최대 20만 원, 11월 30일까지
39 readers so far
Make Korean friends & friends from around the world learning Korean
Chat easily with people from many countries who love Korea.
Beauty UP
대학생 가성비 기초 루틴 — 꼭 필요한 3단계만 남기기
106 readers so far
Psych UP
나의 돈 성향 테스트｜저축 다람쥐? 오늘만 사는 플렉서?
2 people have taken it so far
Criticism and debates
The oldest critique was Hamilton's: a list might suggest unlisted rights don't exist. The Ninth Amendment was Madison's answer, but courts have rarely relied on it, which some scholars think proves Hamilton right.
Others point out who was left out in 1791. The Bill of Rights coexisted with slavery and gave women and Native Americans little protection in practice. Its promises became broadly real only after the Civil War amendments and the civil rights movement.
And the fights today are about interpretation. Should the Second Amendment be read by 1791 history (as in New York State Rifle & Pistol Ass'n v. Bruen, 2022)? Does the Fourth Amendment's "papers and effects" cover your phone's location data? (Carpenter v. United States, 2018, said yes, a warrant is generally required.)
It's a little humbling that a single page from 1791 still decides whether police can read your text messages. The drafters had quill pens; we have cloud storage. The words stayed the same, and the hard part has always been deciding what they reach.
Using the Bill of Rights in exams and papers
- Memory trick: 1–2 freedoms, 3–4 home and privacy, 5–8 justice system, 9–10 structure.
- Essay angle: "Federalists vs. Anti-Federalists" for history; "incorporation" for constitutional law; "negative vs. social rights" for comparative law.
- Korean study material: Essay Answers on the Constitutional Ruling Upholding Takju Supply-Area Restrictions: Least-Restrictive-Means Review, Epistemic Reasons, Treating People Merely as Means, and the Presumption of Innocence and Burden of Proof works through Korean proportionality review and the presumption of innocence, useful when you compare U.S. and Korean rights limits.
- What are the 10 amendments in the Bill of Rights?
- Freedom of religion, speech, press, assembly and petition (1); arms (2); no quartering (3); searches (4); due process and self-incrimination (5); criminal trials (6); civil juries (7); bail and punishment (8); unlisted rights (9); reserved powers (10).
- When was the Bill of Rights ratified?
- December 15, 1791.
- Who wrote the Bill of Rights?
- James Madison drafted it in the First Congress, drawing on state declarations such as Virginia's 1776 Declaration of Rights.
- Does the Bill of Rights apply to states?
- Mostly yes today, through incorporation under the 14th Amendment, though a few provisions still apply only federally.
References and official sources
- The Bill of Rights: A Transcription. archives.gov
- Constitution Annotated, Amendments. congress.gov
- Barron v. Baltimore, 32 U.S. 243 (1833). Justia
- Bill of Rights: Primary Documents in American History. Library of Congress
- Bill of Rights, Wex. Cornell LII
- 대한민국헌법 제2장 국민의 권리와 의무. 국가법령정보센터