CampusDownWiki
Total citations 126,015한국어KO 12,862EnglishEN 77,490日本語JA 9,775中文ZH 25,888
CampusDown ↗
English

Mercer's maternal role attainment theory

🩺 Nursing & Health By CampusDown Wiki Editorial Team Last updated
A middle-range theory of how a woman gains competence and a maternal identity through interaction with her infant from pregnancy through the first year
Contents
  1. 1. Key takeaways
  2. 2. Who developed it and why
  3. 3. Core concepts of Maternal role attainment
  4. 4. Research and evidence behind Maternal role attainment
  5. 4.1. Propositions (testable hypotheses)
  6. 4.2. Key studies and findings
  7. 5. Key assumptions
  8. 6. Maternal role attainment and the nursing metaparadigm
  9. 7. Applying Maternal role attainment to the nursing process: a case example
  10. 8. Strengths and limitations
  11. 8.1. Strengths
  12. 8.2. Limitations
  13. 9. How it compares with related theories
  14. 10. Related nursing theory pages
  15. 11. FAQ
  16. 12. References

Mercer's maternal role attainment theory is a middle-range theory by American nurse scholar Ramona Mercer. It explains how a woman, through interaction with her baby, gains competence in the mothering role and forms a maternal identity. Building on her mentor Reva Rubin's work, Mercer placed the influences in Bronfenbrenner's ecological model, and in 2004 proposed renaming the process Becoming a Mother to capture its dynamic nature.

Key takeaways

  • Attaining the maternal role is a process from pregnancy to about a year after birth, not a moment.
  • Besides mother and infant traits, family (microsystem), work and childcare (mesosystem) and culture and policy (macrosystem) shape it.
  • In a first-year study, role behaviours peaked at 4 months and dipped at 8 months: competence does not grow in a straight line.

Who developed it and why

Ramona T. Mercer worked as a nurse before earning her doctorate at the University of Pittsburgh, where she studied under Reva Rubin, a pioneer of research on the maternal role. She then spent many years teaching and researching at the University of California, San Francisco.

In 1967 Rubin described how pregnant women take on the maternal role by copying other mothers, imagining themselves as mothers, and sorting out what fits. Rubin's observations were mostly of married adult women. Mercer wondered how things differed for teenage mothers, older mothers and mothers of ill infants. Starting with a 1976 study of becoming a mother at sixteen, she studied mothers of different ages and situations, and in 1981 combined role theory with research on infant traits into a framework of variables affecting the maternal role. She later borrowed Bronfenbrenner's ecological model to place mother and baby inside the nested circles of family, community and society.

Core concepts of Maternal role attainment

  • Maternal role attainment — An interactional, developmental process in which a mother becomes competent in caring for her infant and takes the role into her identity.
  • Maternal identity — Internalising oneself as a mother; the end point of the process.
  • Anticipatory stage — During pregnancy: expecting and preparing for the role by watching other mothers and imagining the baby.
  • Formal stage — After birth: acting "by the book" according to experts and others.
  • Informal stage — Developing her own ways of mothering.
  • Personal stage — Feeling harmony and confidence in the role; maternal identity is achieved.
  • Maternal traits — Age, perception of the birth experience, early separation, social stress, support, self-esteem, child-rearing attitudes and health.
  • Infant traits — Temperament, appearance, responsiveness and health. The baby actively influences the mother.

Research and evidence behind Maternal role attainment

Mercer tested her theory for decades and revised it to fit the results, which is rare among theorists. These are the main hypotheses examined and what the studies found.

Propositions (testable hypotheses)

  1. Maternal role behaviours (love for the baby, gratification, observed mothering) rise steadily over the first year. Not supported.
  2. Maternal age affects the level and pattern of role attainment.
  3. Prior mothering experience increases attachment to the infant.
  4. Attachment to the fetus predicts attachment to the infant after birth.
  5. Maternal identity is not achieved once and for all but re-formed with each new challenge.

Key studies and findings

  • Theoretical framework (1981): based on role theory, knowledge of infant traits and a literature review, it set out the variables that influence or are influenced by the maternal role and the design of a study in progress.
  • Maternal role attainment over the first year (1985): mothers aged 15–19, 20–29 and 30–42 were followed for a year. Love for the baby, gratification and observed behaviour did not rise in a straight line; they peaked at 4 months and dipped at 8 months. Interviews linked the challenges of the infant’s development at 8 and 12 months to feelings of incompetence. Levels differed by age group but patterns were similar, and there were no age differences in role strain or self-image as a mother.
  • Experienced vs first-time mothers (1994): 136 experienced and 166 first-time mothers were measured in hospital and at 1, 4 and 8 months. Attachment did not differ at any point; for first-time mothers, fetal attachment explained 11%, then 7%, then 4% of the variance.
  • Becoming a mother (2004): synthesising research from the theory and on the transition to motherhood, Mercer concluded that maternal identity keeps evolving and the term maternal role attainment should be discontinued.

Against the intuition that mothers simply get better over time, the research showed that confidence rises and falls with the baby’s development, and that finding drove the theory’s revision.

Key assumptions

  • Maternal identity forms over time through interaction with the infant.
  • The infant is an active partner who influences the mother’s role performance.
  • The father or partner is one of the mother’s most important sources of support.
  • Family, community and culture can facilitate or hinder role attainment.

Maternal role attainment and the nursing metaparadigm

Metaparadigm conceptHow this theory defines it
PersonA woman growing into motherhood through her personality, experience and relationship with her baby.
EnvironmentBronfenbrenner's micro-, meso- and macrosystems, from family to culture and policy.
HealthThe physical and emotional health of mother and infant, and the attainment of competence and identity.
NursingThe professional closest to the mother from pregnancy through infancy who helps her attain the role.

Applying Maternal role attainment to the nursing process: a case example

An assessment using Mercer’s theory during the second stage of becoming a mother (acquaintance, learning and physical recovery).

Case Woman, 29, first baby, two weeks after an emergency caesarean. Breastfeeding is not going well and she often cries, saying "maybe I’m not cut out to be a mother". Her husband returns to work next week; her own family lives far away. The baby is healthy but fussy.

Nursing process stepApplication
AssessmentMother: negative perception of an unexpected birth, low self-esteem / Infant: fussy temperament / Microsystem: husband returning to work, little family support / Stage: formal, pressure to do it "by the book"
DiagnosisIneffective breastfeeding; risk for parental role conflict; risk for postpartum depression
PlanningWithin one week she reads hunger cues, uses two feeding positions on her own and says "I can do this"
ImplementationListen to her birth story / teach positions and infant cues, explain fussy temperament / plan shared care with her husband / refer to a breastfeeding group and home visits / screen with the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale
EvaluationAfter a week she reads cues, feeds succeed more often, and she says "I’m slowly becoming a mum": goal met; reassess competence at 4 and 8 months

This is a fictional teaching case. Real patient care must follow local protocols and the judgment of the treating team.

Strengths and limitations

Strengths

  • Gives a clear structure for maternal–infant nursing from pregnancy to infancy.
  • Tested in longitudinal studies, and revised in light of the findings.
  • Looks beyond the mother to the baby, partner and wider environment.

Limitations

  • So many variables that the whole model is hard to test at once.
  • Built mainly on data from Western, middle-class heterosexual couples.
  • Does not directly address fathers or same-sex parents becoming parents.
AspectMercerRubinMeleis transitions
FocusMaternal role and identityMaternal tasks in pregnancy and puerperiumAny life transition
Time framePregnancy to about 1 yearPregnancy to puerperiumVaries
HallmarkEcological model, longitudinal studiesDescriptive observationTypes, conditions, indicators

See Meleis's transitions theory for parenthood as a life transition, Bowlby's attachment theory for the emotional bond, and Bronfenbrenner's ecological systems theory for the nested-circle model.

FAQ

What are the stages?
Anticipatory, formal, informal and personal. The 2004 version: commitment, attachment and preparation (pregnancy); acquaintance, learning and physical restoration (2–6 weeks); moving toward a new normal (2 weeks–4 months); achievement of maternal identity (around 4 months).
Why rename it?
"Attainment" suggests a one-off achievement, but identity keeps changing as each new stage of the baby brings challenges, so Mercer proposed "becoming a mother".
How is Mercer linked to Rubin?
Rubin supervised Mercer’s doctorate; Mercer extended Rubin’s concept to mothers of different ages and situations and tested it empirically.
Do older mothers do better?
In the 1985 study, age groups functioned at different levels but followed similar patterns over the year, with no age differences in role strain or self-image as a mother.
Does experience increase attachment?
In 1994, experienced and first-time mothers did not differ in attachment at any time point.

Sources reviewed: 2026-11-20

References

  1. Rubin, R. (1967). Attainment of the maternal role: Part I. Processes. Nursing Research, 16(3), 237–245. Reva Rubin's first description of how women take on the maternal role; the root of Mercer's work.
  2. Mercer, R. T. (1981). A theoretical framework for studying factors that impact on the maternal role. Nursing Research, 30(2), 73–77. The original framework of variables that influence the maternal role.
  3. Mercer, R. T. (1985). The process of maternal role attainment over the first year. Nursing Research, 34(4), 198–203. Follows mothers in three age groups over the first year; source of the 4-month peak and 8-month dip.
  4. Mercer, R. T., & Ferketich, S. L. (1994). Maternal-infant attachment of experienced and inexperienced mothers during infancy. Nursing Research, 43(6), 344–351. Compares attachment in 136 experienced and 166 first-time mothers.
  5. Mercer, R. T. (2004). Becoming a mother versus maternal role attainment. Journal of Nursing Scholarship, 36(3), 226–232. Proposes replacing maternal role attainment with becoming a mother.
  6. Mercer, R. T. (1986). First-time motherhood: Experiences from teens to forties. Springer Publishing. Book reporting first-time mothers from their teens to their forties.
  7. Mercer, R. T. (1995). Becoming a mother: Research on maternal identity from Rubin to the present. Springer Publishing. Synthesises maternal identity research from Rubin onward.
  8. Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). The ecology of human development: Experiments by nature and design. Harvard University Press. The ecological model behind Mercer's nested circles.

Found this helpful? Share it

Send it to a friend who needs it.

X Facebook Threads

Reports and materials that use this theory (Korean)

There are no materials dedicated to this theory yet, but you can search related reports in the CampusDown library (Korean).

Find more reports · Search '머서의 모성역할획득 이론' on CampusDown →

You may also like

This article was last updated on November 20, 2026. It is based on widely recognized original works and textbooks; when citing it in a paper, please check the original sources listed in the references.